Pricing

How We Price Our Toys

At Anew Toy, every stuffed animal gets a second chance at love—and we believe in being transparent about what you're buying. That’s why we use a simple grading system to determine pricing based on each toy’s condition.

A Grade – Like New

These toys are in excellent condition, with no visible signs of wear. They look and feel almost brand new—clean, plush, and ready to impress.
Price Range: Premium

B Grade – Gently Loved

These toys may show minor signs of wear, like slight fading or softening of fabric, but they’re still in great shape and full of charm. Think of them as a well-loved storybook: a little worn, but full of character.
Price Range: Mid-range

C Grade – Well Worn, Well Loved

These toys have clearly been someone’s favorite—maybe a bit threadbare or marked—but they’ve still got plenty of heart. We clean and refresh them carefully, so they’re safe and snuggle-ready, even if they’re a little scrappier.
Price Range: Lower

No matter the grade, every Anew Toy is thoroughly cleaned, inspected, and ready for its next adventure. Choosing secondhand keeps toys out of landfills and stories in circulation.